Whitmer vetoes McBroom bill to let 1-time DUI offenders clear record
LANSING, Mich. (AP) — Gov. Gretchen Whitmer refused to sign a bill that would have let an estimated 200,000 one-time drunken drivers ask a judge to set aside their conviction, despite the measure’s broad bipartisan support in the Michigan Legislature.
The Democrat took no action on the expungement legislation Monday, allowing it to die when a 14-day review period expired. Her office gave no reason why.
The legislation had passed the Senate 32-5 and the House 96-8. A key Republican who helped guide the bill through the GOP-led Legislature expressed outrage.
“I am incredulous,” said Rep. Graham Filler, of DeWitt, who chaired the House Judiciary Committee last term. He said the governor’s pocket veto came “out of nowhere.” The bill was supported by top officials including Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel and state Supreme Court Chief Justice Bridget McCormack — both Democrats — and former House Speaker Lee Chatfield, a Republican.
Michigan currently does not allow someone to petition a court to set aside a conviction for operating a vehicle while intoxicated. The bill would have lifted that prohibition for a first-time offender except if he or she caused another person’s death or serious impairment of a bodily function.
“Everybody knows an individual who screwed up, who had a couple beers, drove home, got popped at that 0.08 (blood alcohol level), spent the night in jail, paid the price,” Filler said. “It’s really bad. They’ve learned their lesson. … This gives them the chance to clean up their public record and move on. How does the governor explain the veto for those people?”
He noted that in October, Whitmer signed sweeping bipartisan “clean slate” legislation to automatically set aside certain criminal records after a number of years and to ease the application process for those convicted of marijuana offenses. She signed similar bills related to juvenile offenders on Monday.
The latest measure would not have provided for automatic expungement of DUI convictions. A judge would have reviewed any request and made a decision.
The sponsor, Republican Sen. Ed McBroom of Vulcan, called the veto “quite disappointing and surprising.” He estimated that more than 200,000 people could have benefited — those who have completed their sentence and who have one offense only.
In Michigan, an expungement — or set aside — clears the public record of a conviction so it does not appear in a background check. Law enforcement still keeps a non-public record, but people no longer have to disclose their criminal past on job applications or other forms.
People with a DUI on their record can be greatly hampered in their careers, McBroom said, especially those who need a commercial driver’s license.
“This one incident in their life, sometimes 30 years ago, is still keeping them down. To not allow judges to at least have the discretion … just seems really unfair,” he said, when an expungement is possible for crimes such as assault and theft.
There were about 30,000 arrests for operating under the influence of alcohol or drugs in 2019, according to the state police.