Inspector wants more veterinary care for IM City Park deer herd
- SOME OF THE deer herd linger near the pool in the pen at Iron Mountain’s City Park, including two does with new fawns. The Canada geese and ducks that use the pool and hang around the pen have led to water quality issues, officials said.
- A DOE WITH twins in the deer pen Sunday at Iron Mountain’s City Park. The bucks have been left intact, which means a new round of fawns in the pen each spring. (Betsy Bloom/Daily News photo)

SOME OF THE deer herd linger near the pool in the pen at Iron Mountain’s City Park, including two does with new fawns. The Canada geese and ducks that use the pool and hang around the pen have led to water quality issues, officials said.
IRON MOUNTAIN — The lack of an adequate program of veterinary care for the deer kept at Iron Mountain’s City Park could mean the end of herd unless the city is willing to improve the pen and find a veterinarian who’ll take on the role.
That’s the message city council members received Friday from City Manager Jordan Stanchina, who also reported six deer were culled Wednesday under pressure from a USDA veterinary medical officer.
Stanchina provided the information as the city council prepares to have a regularly scheduled meeting at 6 p.m. today at City Hall.
In her inspection report, Brianna Waldrop of the USDA said the city by June 13 must have an attending veterinarian and a program of regularly scheduled visits to oversee the adequacy of care. Timely and accurate information on problems with the animals should be communicated to the veterinarian so they can be evaluated, she said.
Brian Scott, an Iron Mountain veterinarian who assisted with a herd assessment, concluded that deficiencies at the pen “create an inhumane environment for the deer, compromising their welfare.” The problems, he said, include insufficient shade, grazing and shelter, along with poor water quality. He confirmed Waldrop’s assessment that at least six deer exhibited abnormal conditions requiring care.

A DOE WITH twins in the deer pen Sunday at Iron Mountain’s City Park. The bucks have been left intact, which means a new round of fawns in the pen each spring. (Betsy Bloom/Daily News photo)
However, Scott said, the lack of a reliable identification system and proper separation and handling capabilities “render it impossible to implement an effective veterinary program for examinations or treatments.”
Stanchina, in his update to the council, said efforts to find an attending veterinarian are complicated by the pen’s deficiencies. It appears “expensive upgrades” would be needed to meet compliance standards, he said.
“If there is no intent to upgrade the deer pen, then, according to Dr. Scott’s letter, all the deer must be removed,” Stanchina told the council. “We understand that the deer can only be removed if they are dead. We will confirm whether this is still the only option available.”
The city council earlier this year sought input from the community on whether to keep the attraction, which dates back more than 75 years. During a Feb. 17 meeting, nine people spoke on the issue, with seven favoring a move toward eliminating the pen.
The herd, at that time, numbered 24 animals. Waldrop during a May 13 inspection counted 21deer and noted one new fawn as of May 19.
At the Feb. 17 session, Mayor Dale Alessandrini raised the possibility of castrating all of the bucks in the herd to allow it to die off naturally. That move, he noted, would also require improvements at the 6-acre pen to address deficiencies.