Breaking News
Editorials

Community colleges must help Michigan develop workforce

By The Detroit News 4 min read

Here's more hard evidence that at every level our schools are not OK: a comprehensive examination by Business Leaders for Michigan finds the state's community colleges rank among the worst in the nation. The dismal performance matters because the two-year schools play a critical role in developing a skilled workforce.

The numbers are embarrassing. Over the past decade, enrollment in Michigan community colleges has fallen 56%, dropping our ranking to 48th in the nation. Just 27% of students complete their degree or certificate programs within six years, placing Michigan at 49th among the states.

When combined with the dismal performance of our K-12 public school system and too-weak graduation rates from public universities, Michigan's education attainment rank is 37th in the nation, and last in the Midwest.

That's not good enough to keep the state competitive in an employment market that is demanding workers with higher skill levels and more education.

"At a time when the state's population is shrinking, and we are losing young talent to knowledge economy hubs, we must take immediate steps to be more competitive," the report concludes. "Businesses and people follow opportunity. Failure to act will cost us exponentially more -- through low state rankings, out migration and employers choosing to grow elsewhere. Community colleges can become one of our greatest assets for building a more robust talent pipeline and strengthening our state's economy."

So how does Michigan get there? For one thing, there must be clarity about what we want from the state's 28 community college districts and hold them to those expectations.

The schools are set up to serve two purposes: prepare students to move on to a four-year university to attain a bachelor's degree, and to provide specific vocational training to students seeking jobs in medical, technical and manufacturing fields that don't require advanced degrees.

Meeting the first goal will require more cooperation between the community colleges and the universities. Curriculums should be shaped so that every credit earned at a community college is fully transferable to every university in the state.

More partnerships should be developed to make sure community college students are prepared to advance and succeed at the next level.

For the second mission, community colleges must be better attuned to the job needs of their communities. Employers looking to site or expand their facilities should be able to turn to community colleges to train workers for the jobs they are creating. Certainty of employment is a powerful motivator for completing a certificate program as quickly as possible.

The Business Leaders report suggests following the model of Wayne State University, which raised its graduation rate to 60% in 2022 from 26% in 2011 by increasing counseling services, providing extra support for struggling and high-risk students and expanding help with transportation, child care, tuition and other non-academic needs.

The report also notes Michigan is the only state without state coordination of its community colleges. While independence is an asset in meeting the needs of local communities, some state-level oversight would be useful in assuring best practices are followed and in measuring performance. That would be a good role for Gov. Gretchen Whitmer's new education department.

Community colleges are getting a $50 million infusion in the new budget, and the Michigan Reconnect program, aimed at helping adults complete their education, is also expanding. Both will help.

Of course, improving outcomes for community colleges rests heavily on getting better results from the K-12 schools. Too many students are graduating from high school unprepared to succeed in college. By nearly every measure, Michigan's public schools are failing.

Without shoring up that foundation, getting better results from community colleges and universities is more challenging.

Starting at /week.