Breaking News
Editorials

Whitmer, Lansing have failed to deliver on transparency

By Detroit News 3 min read

It's been several months since Gov. Gretchen Whitmer had a formal press conference in which she took unfiltered questions from the media. That is setting the tone for an administration that came into office promising transparency and accountability and five years later has delivered neither one.

Press conferences give the public an unscripted lens into government. They are part of the good working of governance.

Yet just last week, after her "What's next" address, the governor took zero questions from reporters to further expand on the progressive platform she presented -- unusually timed after the budget has passed and the legislative session is winding down.

She is happy, however, to sit down with publications that will bolster her national image, including the Atlantic, Vanity Fair and Bloomberg News.

It's not a new approach for Whitmer.

She hid from the press for extensive periods during the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, going for as long as five months at a time without in-person briefings. Instead, her administration would only allow reporters to participate virtually and would select individuals to ask her questions after they had been posted in the video application.

When then-director of the Michigan Department of Human Health and Services Robert Gordon abruptly resigned in 2021, Whitmer -- again, virtually -- refused to answer numerous questions about the nature of his departure.

And she has failed to be transparent on data and decisions related to nursing home deaths during the pandemic.

But there are other transparency issues in Lansing as well, including that Whitmer and the Democratic-led Legislature has done nothing to implement Proposal 1.

That amendment to the state constitution, passed by a broad margin of voters on a ballot measure last fall, requires the Legislature, the governor, secretary of state and attorney general to file annual financial disclosure reports beginning in April 2024.

But in her recent stump speech containing a litany of progressive goals, there was no mention of transparency or government ethics and financial disclosure reform.

Whitmer and lawmakers aren't holding up their end of the bargain, which is to disclose some information about their personal finances. Voters supported these reforms for good reason.

A News investigation, for example, recently found that state Rep. Angela Witwer, D-Delta Township, has maintained a close relationship with the consulting firm she founded while in office, giving one client access to policymakers and representing multiple conflicts of interest.

There's also the curious case of a coding malfunction in Whitmer administration emails that a recent lawsuit alleges is an attempt to evade Freedom of Information Act disclosures regarding unsafe drinking water in Benton Harbor.

Those inside and outside the administration involved insist the incident was not intended to make the warnings about residents' water untraceable. But it turns out it wasn't included in an extensive FOIA search file.

Lawmakers must fulfill their obligation to implement the transparency voters have demanded despite Whitmer's failure to lead by example.

Starting at /week.