Trending
We want to talk about censorship today. A pair of items put it back on our agenda.
It's Banned Books Week. Unlike prior decades, when many of the challenges to books focused on negative depictions of people and the use of racial slurs (think of the challenges to Mark Twain's "Huckleberry Finn"), six of the seven most challenged books over the course of the previous year focused on LGBTQ+ content.
There's no question that such content varies widely in its appropriateness for readers of different ages. The need for a distinction between a young reader in the early grades versus a high school student on the cusp of adulthood is real.
That isn't so different from any other subject, though. You wouldn't drop a first-grade student exploring fractions for the first time into a high school calculus class. It wouldn't be appropriate to bring a course of study that focuses on the detailed history of the Holocaust to a young student, either, without adjusting the approach.
There's a key difference between questioning whether the specific presentation of an issue or concept is appropriate and saying the subject matter is intrinsically inappropriate. Many of the attempts to ban books focus on the latter argument, and it's one with which we don't agree. Schools are places where tricky issues should be discussed in age-appropriate manners.
Let's take this out of the classroom for a moment into the public sphere. We'd argue PBS is, in many respects, the television equivalent of a public library. Just as those libraries have been pressured to remove content, so has PBS.
Back in 1969, when "Sesame Street" first aired, it drew complaints. Not about the blending of fantasy elements (Big Bird) with humans or the fact a major character lived in a trash can. The protests focused on the fact two characters, Gordon and his wife, Susan, were black but lived alongside white neighbors. The PBS station in Jackson, Miss., pulled the show under pressure from viewers.
The drive to remove what makes people the least bit uncomfortable isn't new. It's the wrong approach.
That goes for the second item that brought the subject up this week in our newsroom as well. A recent poll found only 20% of adults think conservative students can speak freely on college campuses. The count of who said the same of liberals was 47% -- not a majority but substantially higher.
The perception cuts across party lines and ideologies. Only 30% of self-identified Democrats believe conservatives can express their views freely on campus. Incidents like students shouting down a judge at Stanford University earlier this year give weight to the argument.
So does the more recent incident in which a conservative professor from Princeton was drowned out while speaking at Washington College in Maryland. The subject? Free speech.
Back in February the UW System released a survey of students' views on free speech. The survey raised some clear concerns. A strong majority -- 57% -- said they had not spoken up about controversial subjects despite the desire to do so. Some 40% said they were concerned their grades would drop for disagreeing with instructors. A substantial portion said schools should ban speech with which they disagree.
In both book bans and college speech, people are failing to understand that disagreement isn't the same as disparagement. Nor does disagreement inflict harm, provided it is expressed calmly.
Libraries and campuses both function best when they are part of a broader marketplace of ideas. Neither should be subjected to bigotry, be it from the left or the right.
Censorship is corrosive. It encourages future erosion of ideas, circumscribing thought within a shrinking circle of what is acceptable. Whether we're talking about the campus or the library, it's a mistake.
Unfortunately, it's a common mistake.