Trending
Robin Vos, the Republican leader of the Wisconsin Assembly, needs to back off the threat to impeach Justice Janet Protasiewicz.
Vos isn't wrong that the members of the Wisconsin Supreme Court need to rule on law, rather than their own political views. His concern for that standard comes late, though, and was notably absent when conservatives held the majority.
On Thursday, Vos said the Legislature has "the ability to hold her accountable to the voters of Wisconsin." He's right. That statement was predicated on whether a justice decides to "inject their own political bias inside the process and not follow the law."
Protasiewicz hasn't done that yet. You have to rule on a case in order to do so. Vos is projecting an outcome that has not yet taken place.
Impeachment of an official is a serious matter. It must be based on that official's actions, not what people believe that official's actions will be. Vos is putting the cart before the horse here, and he's on exceptionally shaky ground in doing so.
Removal of a supreme court justice is an extreme act, warranted only in exceptional circumstances. We've editorialized a number of times about the absence of ethical standards in the United States Supreme Court. As distasteful as we find the justices' actions, not once have we called for removal of a justice. Why not? Because you can't breach a code that doesn't exist, and the court has no binding code of ethics.
There's another dimension in play as well. Protasiewicz was elected by the people of Wisconsin. She took 55% of the vote. Unlike the federal court, justices in Wisconsin are elected to their office and she was the choice of Wisconsin voters.
We're very leery of effectively overturning an election by removing a person voters put in place. While we're concerned about Chippewa County Sheriff Travis Hakes' actions and his apparent lack of judgment, we didn't call for his ouster. Our board did not think his actions quite rose to that level.
It should be no surprise, then, that we do not support the removal of an elected official who has not yet taken the action for which removal is being considered.
Protasiewicz's comments during the election, calling legislative maps "rigged" and "unfair" were unwise. She knew challenges to the maps would likely be coming to the court and that, she would be ruling on them if she won election. She put herself in a position to be accused -- with considerable justification -- of prejudging the cases.
But those who seek her impeachment lack foundation. That foundation may only rest on her position relative to the court's ruling. American law accepts preemptive action only in rare cases, and this isn't one of them.
Vos is further undermined by the fact two of his handpicked advisors on the issue have said they do not believe Protasiewicz should be impeached. Jon Wilcox and David Prosser, both conservatives and former members of Wisconsin's supreme court, have both come out in opposition to such a move.
Impeaching an elected official in a panic, while trying to preserve political dominance, is an abuse of the power the Legislature holds. Vos, we suspect, knows that. While such threats may play well with his political base, they would diminish the Legislature's standing and tarnish his own legacy.
There's an adage that advises people, when they find themselves in a hole, to stop digging. That's the best course for Vos. Clinging to this threat when even a handpicked panel rejects it does not serve Wisconsin, and it's time to put it to rest.
--Eau Claire Leader-Telegram