Breaking News
Editorials

Lawmakers play dangerous game with energy bills

By The Alpena News 2 min read

Lansing lawmakers this month passed a pair of bills that would give the state, not local authorities, the final say over where large-scale wind and solar projects get built.

Gov. Gretchen Whitmer is expected to sign the package.

Proponents say the bills were necessary to help the state meet its goals of powering homes and businesses with 100% clean energy by 2040. Since wind and solar farms power the grid that benefits Michiganders beyond where those wind and solar farms get built, the state ought to have the final say, proponents argue.

Opponents -- including both lawmakers who represent northeast Michigan, state Rep. Cam Cavitt, R-Cheboygan, and state Sen. Michele Hoitenga, R-Manton -- say the communities where utilities want to build those wind and solar farms ought to have the final say.

"It is a way for the state to push local green energy projects in places where people may not want them, and that decision should be up to the cities and townships," Cavitt told News staff writer Steve Schulwitz for a story.

No matter which side with which you agree, it's clear lawmakers play a dangerous game by trying to force major projects into communities where residents may not want them.

In last week's election, voters in Green Township near Grand Rapids recalled five members of that township's Board of Trustees over the board's support of a Chinese-owned factory that will make batteries for electric vehicles. A township supervisor in a neighboring township also got the ax from voters.

The state, including Whitmer, backed that $2 billion factory.

Factory proponents say it'll create scores of jobs and help the state win the arms race for manufacturing electric vehicles.

Opponents say the factory threatens the environment of the rural community where it'll be built and threatens national security because of the company's links to China.

The recalls apparently won't stop the factory, which a company head last week called "a done deal," but they make clear that voters will make their voices heard when they're displeased.

And many are displeased with lawmakers' most recent energy policy reform.

Whitmer and the Democrats who control the Legislature would be wise to keep that in mind.

Starting at /week.