Trending
If one only reads the Unemployment Insurance Agency's take on the December 2023 Office of Auditor General's audit of the state's UIA, they may miss a few things -- namely that the agency continues to insufficiently identify and investigate fraudulent claims. Still, after its fifth audit.
The OAG found:
-- UIA under-calculated fraud penalties by almost half, resulting in $840 million in uncollected payments.
-- The agency's investigative arm failed to identify 70% of imposters filing claims; recover 96.7% of related payments; or refer 90% of cases to law enforcement.
-- $245 million potentially went to the jailed, deceased, and residents in long-term care; and even after determining claimants were deceased or jailed, UIA paid out $1.7 million to them.
And so on.
We don't doubt the difficulty the agency had contending with the staggering spike in jobless claims made during and after pandemic shutdowns. We recall in vivid detail the MiDAS system that made false accusations against legitimately claimed unemployment benefits, even before the pandemic; the crashing UIA phone and computer system during the pandemic; the almost 700,000 people impacted by a mistake the agency made in assigning benefits, and so on.
We also recall that, when the smoke cleared in December 2021, the UIA had paid out an estimated $5.6 billion in fraudulent claims. For context, this is roughly the same amount it might cost to buy Macy's chain of stores, or 1,000 AI-driven unmanned combat aircraft, or what the entire American public lost to scammers in 2021.
But the UIA response to this most recent audit doesn't leave us feeling the fraught agency is on the mend -- because UIA officials appear to prefer the road of righteous self-pity instead of taking its licks.
The response extols agency and director virtues, enumerates wins, offers excuses and assigns blame, such as:
"UIA noted that every pandemic-rooted issue raised by OAG had previously been addressed by the agency and has either been solved or will be resolved as soon as possible. Major reform takes time."
"Confusing federal guidelines and a dysfunctional technology system implemented under former Gov. Rick Snyder created many of the claims processes issues cited in today's audit."
The response also was laced with phrases such as "questionable audit conclusions," "not a true sample of all the hard work," and that staff "followed established procedures."
How does this blame shift continue to happen through UIA's 11 directors in 11 years?
We hope the Legislature continues to push for reform, and does not let this be the final audit in the UIA saga. If the response shows anything, it's that the agency is still plagued by an expensive, defensive lack of self-awareness.